News RSS Feed


Alternative cinema plans unveiled

11:05am Thursday 1st February 2007

comment Comments (4)   Have your say »

By Neil Skinner »

ALTERNATIVE plans for the development of the contested Bricket Road cinema site were revealed last night (Wednesday, January 31) by St Albans Civic Society.

A packed public meeting at Dagnall Street Baptist Church, St Albans, was told that the current plans were "monstrous", threatening to damage irreparably the rich cultural heritage of the city by setting a benchmark of shoddy architecture.

Speakers, including a number of respected architects and engineers, warned that the proposals - complete with more than 170 flats - would dominate the skyline for miles around and even threaten St Albans Abbey as a focal point.

The society had intended to showcase plans by award-winning Italian architect Cesary Bednarski but a representative was unable to attend for family reasons.

The packed meeting was told, however, by stand- in Alan McCartney that the proposals included a two screen (not seven) cinema with limited residential accommodation to be built on top of the existing council car park.

The proposals, it was claimed, would be cheaper, better, and more in keeping with their surroundings than those currently on the table.

Council claims that the existing structure could not support such a development were later dismissed by Mr McCartney, an experienced structural engineer.

Civic society chairman Eric Roberts welcomed the alternative proposals but stressed the need to defeat the current proposals before an expected decision at a council planning meeting on Wednesday, March 14.

Speaking of what was at stake, he concluded:"The existing city skyline looks stunning and I can't understand why some of our councillors seem set on ruining that for ever. It really hurts me."

Your Say YourSt Albans

mark, st albans says...
4:05pm Thu 1 Feb 07

its about time we did something with our city centre, its boring and a cinema is just what we need. ok the abbey is nice to look at but our skyline could do with a few more high-rise building!

Karen, says...
6:59pm Fri 16 Feb 07

More high-rise buildings are just what this city doesn't need! This isn't Hemel or Watford, this is a low-level city with some very pretty architecture. Even the 1960s additions in the city centre haven't completely ruined it, but if this cinema gets accepted it will pave the way for even more ugly, brutalist architecture.

One person has pointed out, rightly, how the IMAX cinema in Bournemouth was touted as a great thing for the community. Three years later it closed, leaving its outsized concrete hulk to ruin the beachfront for the residents. Listen, people! Let's not make the same mistake twice!

Dave, St. Albans says...
12:03am Mon 19 Feb 07

St. Albans has young people living here too - an art house cinema would be fantastic; in the old Odeon building on the London Road - St. Albans needs a multiplex cinema and behind the alban arena is a perfect place for it - the buliding being submited by henry davidson is a bold contemporary structure that dosn't detract from the main focal points of the city (The Abbey, St. Peter's Church) - its a welcome addition to the city centre, a city centre in desperate need of something to bring more people into the centre - a multiplex added with 170 appartments will go along way in achiveing this. St. Albans can't remain in the past, its not a museum - not yet anyway.

Pete, St Albans says...
10:51pm Wed 21 Feb 07

I agreed with Dave about the need for a cinema in the city centre until he said "bold contemporary structure which doesn't detract..." The developer's own visualisations show tacky design which grossly intrudes into the St Albans syline - and these are supposed to show how unobtrusive it will be! We certainly don't want to live in a museum and we do need more people living near the centre of town but not a ten-storey tower. There is plenty of space for housing on the Tesco land on London Road. Which leads to another debate.

Your sayYourSt Albans

comment Add your comment

Register for a FREE St Albans & Harpenden Review account and you can have your say on today's news and sport by adding comments on articles we publish. The best comments may even get published in the paper.

Please register now or sign in below to continue.




Forgotten your password?

Hot Jobs


Local Advertisers


Local Information

Enter your postcode, town or place name

House prices »   Schools »   Crime »   Hospitals »